Question 1
All of the following cause compressive atelectasis EXCEPT (2004 old paper)
- A. Pneumothorax
- B. Asthma
- C. Congestive cardiac failure
- D. Pleural effusion
Show answer and rationale
Correct answer: B — Asthma
Asthma (B) does not cause compressive atelectasis; it leads to resorption atelectasis via mucus plugs obstructing airways, trapping gas that's resorbed, collapsing alveoli. Compressive atelectasis results from external pressure on lung tissue. Pneumothorax (A) compresses lung via air in the pleural cavity. Congestive cardiac failure (C) causes fluid buildup (e.g., pleural effusion or pulmonary edema), compressing alveoli. Pleural effusion (D) collapses lung via fluid pressure. Peritonitis (original E) elevates the diaphragm, compressing lungs. Page 714 notes compression atelectasis shifts mediastinum away from the affected lung, unlike resorption's shift toward it. Asthma's mechanism bronchial obstruction differs from the external compression of A, C, D, relying on mucus rather than pleural or parenchymal pressure, making B the exception.